Hi, Ellie vs spreadsheets & lye calculators
Most makers run on a spreadsheet or a notebook, and a free online lye calculator for soap. Both are good tools. Here is what each one does, and where Hi, Ellie fits.
| What it does | Hi, Ellie | Spreadsheet or notebook | Free online lye calculator |
|---|---|---|---|
| Knows what’s on your shelf | Yes — your pantry tracks what you have on hand | Only if you update it by hand | No — you enter the oils for each recipe |
| Builds a recipe from it and flags gaps | Yes — from your real shelf; anything you don’t own is flagged | No — you write the recipe | No — you pick the oils, it does the lye math |
| Lye and preservative amounts | Lye and water, and a lotion’s minimum preservative weight, worked out by the app | Only the formulas you build yourself | Lye and water — that’s its job |
| A hard stop before a lye batch counts | Yes — you confirm a lye safety card before a step counts or a batch completes | No | No — it calculates; the batch is yours to run |
| Cost per batch (COGS) | On the Maker and Studio plans | If you build the formulas | Not usually |
| Batch history and notes | Yes — a batch records what you noticed and draws what you used from your pantry | If you log it | Not usually |
| Flexibility | Built for resin, candle and Bath & Body | Fully flexible — any column, any craft | One job, done quickly |
| Price | A free plan with no time limit; Maker and Studio are paid | Free | Free |
| Account | Yes — you sign in | Not needed | Not needed |
Where they win
A spreadsheet is free and fully flexible: any column, any craft, any layout you like. A free online lye calculator is free, needs no account, and does one job quickly. If a sheet and a calculator cover what you make, they are a fine way to work.
Hi, Ellie is for when you want the shelf, the recipe and the batch in one place. See pricing or start free.
Questions we hear at the workbench.
Can I import what I already have in a spreadsheet? +
Yes. Grab the free sample template, fill it in, and upload it as an XLSX workbook (export one from Google Sheets, Numbers or Excel) — Ellie maps the columns for you. The template and export are free on every plan; the bulk import itself is a Maker feature.
Do I still need a lye calculator? +
Keep one. A from-scratch recipe’s lye and water weights are worked out in code from each oil’s SAP value and your superfat. You confirm the lye safety card before a step counts or a batch completes. Our lye safety guide still says to double-check the exact lye amount yourself with a dedicated calculator before mixing — a free online lye calculator is a good way to do that.
Is there a free plan? +
Yes — no card and no time limit. It holds 50 inventory items and 3 recipe-wizard sessions a month.